Curriculum
Course: Mentorship Practice: Becoming a Better M...
Login
Text lesson

Help that leaves the decision with the mentee

The difference between support and taking over

A mentee can finish a conversation feeling relieved while becoming more dependent on the mentor. If you choose the goal, supply the solution and chase every action, the apparent progress is largely yours. Developmental mentoring aims to increase the mentee’s ability to understand a situation, weigh options and act. It can include sharing experience, but that experience is evidence to consider, not an instruction to copy.

Fictional case: Thato, a supervisor in a Gqeberha shop, asks Naledi to choose a qualification for him. Naledi completed a diploma ten years ago. “Do my course; it worked for me” hides several differences: current entry rules, Thato’s shifts, transport costs and his intended work. A more useful opening is, “What are you hoping the qualification will make possible, and which constraint makes the choice difficult?” Thato names changing shifts. That changes the task from ranking prestigious courses to testing feasible study arrangements.

Three roles that must stay visible

The mentee owns the development goal and the final choice. The mentor offers attention, questions, relevant experience and challenge within their competence. Any programme sponsor sets actual programme rules and safety or reporting obligations. A manager who also mentors has additional power over work; they must say when a conversation is about a performance requirement rather than pretend every topic is optional mentoring.

Try a two-column rewrite. On the left, write three rescue statements you might use: “I will fix your CV”, “I will speak to the manager for you”, “You should take that job”. On the right, preserve useful support while returning ownership: “Which part of the CV needs evidence? I can respond to a draft you write.” In a real power imbalance, do not assume saying “your choice” removes the pressure. Ask whether the person can decline your suggestion without consequences.

Read your revised statements aloud. They should name a useful offer, retain the mentee’s decision and avoid a guarantee you cannot fulfil. If a statement only withdraws help, add a specific contribution. Save one paragraph describing your role and its limits; you will turn it into the agreement in the next lesson.